Home › Methodology
Open methodologyHow the cross-border math works
The full method behind the Retire Abroad comparison and the data study — what is taxed where, how the treaty credit really behaves, and which simplifications the model makes. Written so you can check it rather than trust it.
The shape of the calculation
Income is simulated month by month, not projected with an annual formula. Each month the model draws the requested amounts from each account, works out the tax due on that year's income, applies healthcare cost, and grows the remaining balances. Phase figures are the average of the months inside them.
Phases are cut at the ages where the arithmetic genuinely changes — 65 (Medicare replaces marketplace insurance), the Social Security claim age, 73 (Required Minimum Distributions begin, on the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table) and 80. Putting a boundary on the claim age matters: it means Social Security never starts halfway through a phase, so every phase is either wholly before or wholly after it.
Brackets, deductions, thresholds and healthcare costs are inflated per phase, so a bracket ceiling at 80 is not the ceiling that applies at 60.
What each country taxes
United States
Federal brackets of 10 / 12 / 22 / 24 / 32 / 35 / 37% applied to taxable income after the standard deduction and the senior add-on. Social Security is taxed the IRS way — through the provisional-income test, so only a portion becomes taxable rather than all or none. Only the gain portion of a brokerage withdrawal is taxed, and the model taxes it as ordinary income, which is conservative (the real long-term rates of 0, 15 and 20% are usually lower). The Net Investment Income Tax applies above its threshold. State income tax is a flat rate you set; the published comparisons set it to zero.
United Kingdom
The personal allowance, then basic (20%), higher (40%) and additional (45%) bands. Two details that are easy to miss and are modeled here:
- The personal-allowance taper — £1 of allowance is lost for every £2 of income above roughly £100,000, so there is an effective marginal spike in that band.
- Treaty Article 17(3): US Social Security paid to a UK resident is taxable only in the UK, so it is in the UK tax base and out of the US one. This is a saved exception to the treaty's saving clause, so it holds for US citizens too. The UK also taxes 401(k) withdrawals, the UK State Pension, equity gains and any part-time earnings.
Canada
Federal brackets, with the basic personal amount credited at the lowest rate as the T1 return does, plus the provincial rate you set. Under the treaty (Article XVIII), 85% of US Social Security is taxed in Canada and the other 15% is exempt. The full 401(k) withdrawal is taxed as income.
Australia
The tax-free threshold, then 15 / 30 / 37 / 45% (the Stage 3 rates, with the first band at 15% from 1 July 2026), reduced by the Low Income Tax Offset — A$700 below A$37,500, tapering to zero at A$66,667. The Medicare Levy of 2% is then charged on all taxable income once it passes the levy threshold, phased in at 10c per dollar above it. Superannuation withdrawals after 60 are tax-free and are excluded from assessable income.
The Foreign Tax Credit: you pay the higher bill, not the sum
This is the part most write-ups get wrong, so it is worth stating precisely. For a US citizen resident in the UK the model computes both liabilities and then credits one against the other:
credit = min(UK tax, US tax) → US tax payable = US tax − credit
The credit cannot exceed the US liability. Work the algebra through and the total falls out as max(UK tax, US tax) — you pay whichever of the two bills is larger, and never both.
In the data study the UK bill is the larger one in every phase, so the credit cancels the US bill on the 401(k) withdrawals and the UK resident pays the UK bill alone: $607 a month at 60 against the American's $353. From 67 the gap widens, because Article 17(3) puts US Social Security in the UK tax base and takes it out of the US one. The UK bill rises to $850 against the American's $343.
The practical consequence: once Social Security starts, moving between the US and the UK becomes a tax decision again. UK healthcare saves the Medicare premiums the American pays, but in the published base case that saving no longer covers the UK's higher tax after 67.
Healthcare
For a US resident this is modeled in two regimes. Before 65: ACA marketplace premiums, including the 400%-of-federal-poverty-level subsidy cliff and the 250% FPL Silver cost-sharing-reduction band — both driven by MAGI, so a withdrawal decision can move the premium. From 65: Medicare Part B and Part D, plus IRMAA surcharges, which use a two-year income lookback — the surcharge you pay at 67 is set by your income at 65.
For the UK, Canadian and Australian columns the model applies no direct healthcare premium, on the assumption that the public system covers a resident.
This assumption does more work than any other in the model. In the published base case the American pays $456 a month for marketplace cover before 65 and $291–$510 a month for Medicare after it, and before 67 that is what puts the UK ahead. Anything that changes it — private cover, an insurance condition attached to a visa, a surcharge for recent arrivals — moves the answer directly. Treat it as the first thing to challenge, not a footnote.
Simplifications, stated plainly
Every model simplifies. These are the ones that could change a conclusion, so they belong on the page rather than in a disclaimer:
Known asymmetry: US tax abroad
The UK column applies both liabilities and the treaty credit. The Canadian and Australian columns apply local tax only — no US layer — even though a US citizen abroad still has US filing obligations.
Where local tax is higher than the US figure, this makes no difference, because the credit result would be the local bill anyway. In the October 2026 re-run of the data study that is the case in every phase at every portfolio size, from $600k to $2.5M.
It can matter for a smaller plan, or one with more income the US taxes lightly. Where the US figure is the higher one, the Canadian or Australian column understates the tax by the difference and flatters that country.
The rest
- No local social-security entitlements — no CPP, OAS, Age Pension or UK State Pension accrual. The comparison holds the same savings against different tax systems; it is not a comparison of different working lives.
- No currency risk. Everything is priced in US dollars. For destinations where cost arbitrage is the whole proposition, this matters a great deal.
- Fixed exchange rates in the published comparisons. The UK, Canadian and Australian thresholds are converted at fixed rates (£1 = US$1.36, US$1 = C$1.41, US$1 = A$1.41). The paid planner converts them at the rate you use, so its figures for those three countries move with the exchange rate.
- Nominal dollars in the published tables, not inflation-adjusted — though inflation is applied to brackets and thresholds inside the model.
- State income tax set to zero in published comparisons, which flatters the US column.
- Nothing about visas, residency tests or domicile. Whether you may live somewhere is a separate question from what it would cost.
- No destination-country model for other currencies. The planner supports Philippine peso, Thai baht and euro as display currencies with US federal tax only — no local tax model. They are deliberately excluded from these comparisons, because a column showing near-zero tax and zero healthcare would top the table for the wrong reasons.
How it is checked
The engine ships with a golden-master self-test: fixed fixture plans re-run on every build and diffed against known-good values, so silent calculation drift shows up immediately rather than in a customer's plan. Coverage spans all four tax regimes, Social Security claim-age splits, RMDs, NIIT, ACA, early retirement, Roth conversions, pensions and lump sums.
The free comparison tool and the data study run that same engine — not a simplified re-implementation — and the study's generator refuses to produce output unless it first reproduces a twenty-value cross-check against the paid planner, and unless the engine's own identity (net = gross − tax − healthcare) holds for every country in every phase.
That second check is not decoration. It is what caught a real error: the tool had been reporting a UK resident's income tax as $0, because the field it displayed held only the US federal component — which the treaty credit had reduced to nothing. The net income figures were correct throughout; the breakdown row was not. It is fixed, and the check now makes that class of mistake impossible to ship quietly.
See it applied
Read the worked comparison, or put your own numbers through the same engine — free, no sign-up, no email.
This is an educational model, not financial, tax or legal advice, and not a personalized recommendation. Cross-border tax is genuinely complicated — treaty position, domicile and residency tests can all change the answer for an individual. Talk to a qualified cross-border adviser before acting on any of it.